Top 3 Drugstore Foundations for Your Skin Type

This post may contain affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission if you purchase through our links. Please read our full disclosure here.

Drugstore foundation for your skin type

Finding a great foundation can be a difficult and even overwhelming experience. Your friend raved about one foundation, but maybe another one didn’t like it. You read tons of rave reviews about a different foundation online, but when you bought it yourself, it didn’t work for you. Sound familiar?

In general, there are a lot of amazing drugstore foundations out there, but it certainly takes some digging to find them. And the key to finding the one that’s perfect for you? Skin type. It’s the reason one foundation may look amazing on one person but horrible on another. That’s why it is crucial that you assess your skin type before purchasing the product in order to have the most flattering look.

Below, I’ve broken down each of the four most common skin types, and a great drugstore foundation for each (with the exception of “normal” skin, which can wear all three foundations).

Skin Types

In general, there are four main skin types: normal, oily, combination, and dry.

  • Normal: Luckily for you, your skin appears evenly toned and you suffer from few breakouts. Your skin is not overly dry or oily. You can pretty much wear whatever foundation you want – they will all work for you, more or less.
  • Oily: If you notice that your face tends to get shiny after a short period of time, then you probably have oily skin. This is more obvious in the T-Zone area, which is across your forehead and down the bridge of your nose. Oily skin types typically don’t have many dry areas.
  • Dry: Your skin often feels tight and looks flaky. You may get dry patches especially around the nose and chin area. This usually gets worse in the winter.
  • Combination: Your skin displays characteristics of both oily and dry skin. You likely have an oily t-zone (nose, forehead, and chin), but dry patches on the rest of your face.

Now that you have an idea of your skin type, on to the foundations!

Oily Skin – Neutrogena Healthy Skin Liquid Makeup

Neutrogena Healthy Skin liquid makeup - best drugstore foundation for oily skin

Neutrogena Healthy Skin Liquid Foundation – $11.99

Neutrogena’s Healthy Skin foundation is perhaps the best drugstore foundation for oily skin. As a general rule, Neutrogena foundations will not clog your pores or add grease to already-oily skin. In addition, Neutrogena is known for their acne-fighting skincare products, so it makes sense that their foundations would work for problem skin. If you have a history of breaking out due to your foundation, you should definitely consider Neutrogena.

Foundation rundown:

  • Coverage: The coverage of this foundation is moderate to medium. It blends in with your skin beautifully and most importantly looks natural.
  • Biggest Pro: This foundation contains lots of great ingredients and is actually proven to help improve the quality of your skin.
  • Biggest Con: Application can be a pain with the screwtop cap – spilling is usually unavoidable, and don’t even try to get all the product out of the bottle. It’s not going to happen.

Dry Skin – Revlon Colorstay Foundation

Revlon colorstay foundation - best drugstore foundation for dry skin

Revlon’s Colorstay Foundation – $12.99

Although the package says “for combination and oily skin”, I’ve found Colorstay to be the best drugstore foundation for dry skin. Foundations for dry skin typically contain more moisturizing ingredients, and Colorstay fits the bill. In general, if you have dry skin, look for foundations that emphasize their hydrating ingredients. Also, girls with dry skin should always exfoliate before applying foundation. This will help get rid of some of the dry, dead skin cells so the foundation can go on more smoothly.

If you are looking for something a bit lighter than a full-coverage foundation, I also recommend tinted moisturizers for a hint of color minus the heavy look. For example, Covergirl’s CG Smoothers SPF 15 has the perfect ingredients for dry skin users.

Foundation rundown:

  • Coverage: The reason why I recommend Revlon Colorstay over CG Smoothers is because Revlon has much better coverage. Tinted moisturizers for the most part have sheer coverage, while foundations have medium to full.
  • Biggest Pro: The great thing about the Colorstay line is that they have a great variety of colors for all skin types. The coverage is also amazing. I used it on my friend’s sunburned skin once and you could not tell she was sunburned afterwards.
  • Biggest Con: This foundation can feel heavy on your face and sometimes looks too cakey if applied with a heavy hand.

Combination Skin – Revlon PhotoReady Foundation

Revlon PhotoReady Foundation - best drugstore foundation for combination skin

Revlon’s PhotoReady Foundation – $13.99

Combination skin can be tricky to work with. I have combination skin myself and I find that the seasons largely dictate what foundation I wear. For example, during winter, my skin can get really dry so I need a more hydrating foundation, while during the summer, my skin gets shiny the second I walk out into the heat.

If you have combination skin, you may need two foundations – one for winter, and one for summer. That said, I’ve found that Revlon PhotoReady is the best drugstore foundation for combination skin because it works well year-round: wear over moisturizer in winter and under powder in summer.

Foundation rundown:

  • Coverage: Photoready Foundation has beautiful coverage that helps even out your skin tone. The coverage is more moderate than Colorstay.
  • Biggest Pro: This foundation blends in beautifully with your skin tone and doesn’t look unnatural or too cakey.
  • Biggest Con: It does contain shimmer, which may be a problem for ladies with skin on the oilier side. Shimmery foundations can have a tendency to highlight open pores and oily areas, so be sure to use a powder on top if you’re worried about it.

Your thoughts?

I know a bunch of you requested this post so I hope it fit your expectations! Now I want to know what you think – what foundations do you guys enjoy using? Feel free to recommend any other products in the comments section, and be sure to note your skin type.

19 thoughts on “Top 3 Drugstore Foundations for Your Skin Type”

  1. I am always always looking for the best foundation. For the last two and a half years i’ve never gotten the same foundation twice. I still look around the internet to see what other people’s opinions are. But I’ve had all three foundations on this list and was disappointed to read that these are considered the best. Mostly because I like trying new things. But anyways a quick run down on each of the products with my experiences..
    Neutrogena Healthy Skin:
    I loved the idea that it makes your skinn feel better. And it did sort of feel better. But after a while, it seemed to disappear almost like my skin was immune to it haha. &also it sort of felt gross on my skin. But it was still probably 2nd on my list.
    Revlon Colorstay:
    I’ve just ran out of this. I loved the coverage. But it’s so cakey. I can still blend it to make it look more natural but the way it feels as you’re putting it on your face is gross. I purchased the normal/dry and it didn’t help the dry areas but it did make them look oily. Plus I have to top it off with bronzer and powder or else it just doesn’t work well. this is my least favorite of the three.
    lastly:
    Photoready:
    I just remember loving this one, It was a few months ago and it worked really well wasn’t too cakey and I loved the extra sparkle. I’m actually thinking about getting it today, but it’s a bit pricey for ME.

    Reply
  2. I think you have your foundations a little mixed up. The formula in the Revlon Color Stay will make dry skin look cakey. And for that particular Neutrogena product will not just make someone with oily skin more oily, but it will make them break out. Someone with oily skin wants a foundation with a matte finish, NOT dewy! TO PEOPLE WITH OILY/PROBLEMATIC SKIN: upon buying cosmetics, make sure the packaging says “oil-free” or “non-comedogenic”. This will give you reassurance that the product will not cause breakouts.

    BTW, just because Neutrogena makes OTC products for acne, does not mean their makeup with help condition their problem. Read the packaging first…

    Reply
    • Just because the packaging says something doesn’t make it so!
      Revlon Color Stay is actually great for dry skin! Have you tried it or are you just “reading the packaging”?
      Get on Google! You will see that TONS of people say the same thing!

      Reply
  3. Yeah I tried the Neutrogena (based off of this post and other reviews) and did not like it. I have combination/oily skin and it 1. Was annoying to put on because of the packaging.. which is weird because loreal true match does not have a pump but the consistency or something is easier for me to apply/get out of the bottle. 2. Made me more oily. and 3. Made me break out! I returned it (yay CVS!) and now use the Covergirl 3-in-1 foundation with the blue top and it has been AWESOME!! Truly controls the shine and good staying power.

    Reply
  4. oh and i have the Neutragena one, but for some reason I like it better as summer foundation. Feels kinda weird in the winder on my skin.

    Reply
  5. Hey, I was debating on wether or not getting the Revlon colorstay??? I have the Maybelline SuperStay and i love it!!! I have heard that it is really simliar to Revlon Colorstay and have been kinda thinking about trying it. But the only thing is i have pretty normal skin for the most part. Definatly don’t have dry skin, but i think i might be just a little oily in the T-zone like after school. But other then that i don’t get oily ever. So i am confused on which one i should get.But i am wondering which one would be better for me? If someone could give me more details Colorstay oily vs. dry that would be great…thanks 🙂

    Reply
  6. I tried a tinted moisturizer based on the advice here- I only wanted sheer coverage to even out my skin tone- and I LOVE it! Couldn’t find the CG so I got Physicians Formula Organic Wear. Good stuff, I highly recommend it. Thanks for the info!

    Reply
  7. @ Cat,
    I have very sinilar skin issues as you and I’m thinking about trying ColorStay for its coverage. You didn’t mention how its working for you. Id be really curious to know. Particularly w reference to pores, coverage, shininess, but as much info as possible would be great.

    I’m using ALMAY Cclear Complexion w .6% salicylic acid which btw, I think has really GREAT coverage for anyone wantin to cover light-moderate acne/pigmentation. Just hope they hav a color that suits you cus the selection’s slim & runs light. (For all u pale ladies, I hear its great. Tho I can’t say how the coverage is in lighter tones as I’m medium) Google reviews. It comes pretty highly recommended.
    Anyway, thanx a lot guys. Def influenced my next purchase.
    Anyway, thanx a lot Nicole

    Reply

Leave a Comment